Viewers generally hold 'A Bronx Tale' in high regard, praising its compelling portrayal of 1960s Bronx and the complex relationships between a father, his son, and a local gangster. The film is celebrated for its strong performances, particularly by Chazz Palminteri and a young Lillo Brancato, and its thoughtful handling of themes like racial tension and moral dilemmas. While some noted minor flaws in script and direction, the overall sentiment is that De Niro's directorial debut successfully blends drama and crime with a powerful moral message.

👍 Strong performances and deep themes

👎 Some minor script and direction flaws