Viewers generally appreciate 'The One I Loved' for its emotional depth and strong performances, particularly praising Marina Foïs and Roschdy Zem for their portrayals of Simone Signoret and Yves Montand. The film's depiction of the couple's tumultuous relationship, marked by infidelity and emotional struggle, resonates with audiences, offering a mix of nostalgia and drama. While some find the film's approach to biographical storytelling engaging, others critique it for occasional dramatic liberties and a lack of physical resemblance between the actors and the real-life figures.

👍 Strong performances enhance emotional depth.

👎 Some historical inaccuracies noted.