Readers find 'Long Island' emotionally stirring, praising Colm Tóibín's masterful character portrayal and the intricate depiction of human relationships. The narrative, rich in psychological depth, captures the complexities of love and betrayal, set against the backdrop of contrasting cultures. However, some readers felt the plot was somewhat indolent and lacking in credible twists, with a particular critique on the less vibrant cultural and social backdrop compared to Tóibín's previous works.

👍 Masterful character portrayal

👎 Plot may feel slow and predictable