Yes I understand why it was widely criticized. This story was set up well to be a slow burn unfolding of supernatural and psychological terror. Instead we get what feels the director prompting AI to conclude her story in the most artistic and dramatic way possible. George riding his unpaid for boat into the dark hellion abyss turns into the portrait we’ve been seeing all along. There’s no real justice for Cath. Or any other woman who was murdered by their husbands in that house.