Plot holes: Why didn’t the parents move houses? Did they think she was dead? What would the mom have done if when she tapped on the wall the girl tapped back? How did she survive in the walls without any resources? Why would they put their son in the basement knowing their daughter was in there at any point? Who killed the trick or treater? If they hid their daughter in the wall and assumed she died, why wouldn’t they just dispose of the child’s body within that same space? Why would the school immediately assume the kid was violently pushed down the stairs? It would be much more likely Peter would’ve just insisted it was an accident and in elementary school it’s not very likely he would’ve immediately expelled this child. ESPECIALLY if the substitute teacher showed the principal his drawing. If this child was born with deformities it would also be very unlikely it wouldn’t need extra medical care which would’ve made it much harder to hide the child in a pit in the basement. Rat poison takes more than 45 seconds to kill you.

Comments