The reviews for 'The Whale' reveal a mix of deep emotions and critical perspectives. Viewers praised Brendan Fraser's compelling performance, which many felt deserved his Oscar win, highlighting the film's intense emotional depth and the impactful portrayal of complex themes like obesity and redemption. However, some criticized the film for its heavy-handed approach to these themes and its claustrophobic setting, feeling that it sometimes tipped into melodrama without sufficient narrative payoff.

👍 Brendan Fraser's performance is widely celebrated.

👎 Some found the film overly melodramatic and claustrophobic.