The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug is celebrated for its epic scale and the introduction of the dragon Smaug, a highlight that showcases Peter Jackson's powerful direction. Fans appreciate the darker tone and the more substantial role given to the dwarves compared to the first film. The action sequences, especially those involving Legolas and Tauriel, are thrilling, though some viewers noted that the film feels stretched to justify its length. The addition of new characters like Tauriel adds a fresh dynamic, though it sparked some controversy among purists.

👍 Smaug's portrayal is widely praised as a high point of the film.

👎 Some viewers felt the film was unnecessarily elongated.