Opinions on 'The I-Land' are mixed, with viewers captivated by its intriguing premise of amnesiac characters on a mysterious island, which turns out to be a simulation for criminals. While some praise the series for its suspense and ethical questions, others are disappointed by uneven acting, lackluster character development, and a sometimes incoherent plot. The beautiful island scenery is consistently appreciated, but the series overall fails to fully deliver on its potential.

👍 Intriguing premise and ethical exploration

👎 Uneven acting and lackluster plot