The reviews reveal a mixed reception for 'American Gods'. Viewers find the series wildly imaginative, appreciating its daring portrayal of a war between old gods and new. However, there's a consensus that the quality dips after the first season, with some unnecessary scenes and confusing plot points. The unique characters and mythological elements are highlights, yet the lack of a conclusive ending leaves some viewers wanting more.

👍 Imaginative portrayal of mythological war

👎 Inconsistent quality in later seasons